Over the tax-credit cliff: what a family of four pays in 2027

Updated for 2027. The cliff moved: a family of four now loses the whole credit above $132,000 (it was $128,600 for 2026 coverage), and the most a household pays toward the benchmark rose from 9.96% to 10.22% of income. Statewide, the silver benchmark for a 40-year-old rose from $683 to $738 in Florida and from $523 to $595 in Michigan (KFF), so the price one dollar over the line is higher too.

Quick answer

The subsidy cliff is in force for 2027 coverage. Here is what it costs a family of four one dollar over the line, Marketplace vs private, with county-level numbers.

For five years the premium tax credit faded out gently as income rose. That ended on January 1, 2026, and nothing has changed for 2027. The enhanced credits created in 2021 expired at the end of 2025, Congress did not extend them before Open Enrollment for 2027 coverage opened on November 1, 2026, and with them went the rule that capped anyone's benchmark premium at 8.5% of income no matter how much they earned. The original design is in force: the credit is available up to 400% of the federal poverty level and not one dollar beyond it.

For a family of four in the 48 contiguous states that line sits at $132,000 of household income for 2027 coverage, using the 2026 poverty guidelines that apply to this plan year. At $132,000 the family is expected to contribute 10.22% of income, about $1,124 a month, toward the benchmark silver plan, and the credit covers the rest. At $132,001 the credit is zero. That is the cliff, and this guide is about what waits at the bottom of it.

What the credit was doing for you

Take Hillsborough County, Florida, for 2027. Two parents, 40 and 38, with two children. The cheapest Bronze plan for that household lists at $1,632 a month, and the benchmark silver plan, the second-lowest Silver in the county, lists at $2,182. At $85,000 of income the family is at 258% of the poverty level and is expected to contribute 8.90% of income, about $630 a month, toward that benchmark. The credit makes up the difference, roughly $1,552 a month, and because the credit can be applied to any metal tier, the cheapest Bronze plan costs them about $80.

Now give the same family a raise to $135,000. The credit disappears. The cheapest Bronze plan costs the full $1,632 a month, $19,580 a year, for an HMO with an $18,000 family deductible that pays little beyond preventive care until that deductible is met. Silver and Gold cost more: the cheapest Silver is $2,089 and the cheapest Gold $2,022. Nothing about the plans changed; only the subsidy did.

The lines for other household sizes follow the same pattern. Here is the full table for 2027 coverage.

Household size100% of poverty level138% (Medicaid line in expansion states)400% (tax-credit limit)
1$15,960$22,025$63,840
2$21,640$29,863$86,560
3$27,320$37,702$109,280
4$33,000$45,540$132,000
5$38,680$53,378$154,720
6$44,360$61,217$177,440

2026 HHS poverty guidelines for the 48 contiguous states and DC, which apply to 2027 coverage (Alaska and Hawaii are higher). Source: 91 FR 1797 and IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-26.

Full price in five big states

Here is the same family, priced at full Marketplace rates in the most populous county of five HealthCare.gov states, next to the private range our advisors typically quote for a healthy family of that shape.

CountyCheapest BronzeCheapest SilverCheapest GoldPrivate range
Miami-Dade County, FL$1,761$2,339$2,201$580–$1,153
Harris County, TX$1,424$2,082$1,897$532–$1,094
Wake County, NC$1,570$1,779$2,001$485–$1,035
Franklin County, OH$1,402$1,922$2,020$479–$1,028
Wayne County, MI$1,317$1,816$1,864$528–$1,088

Two parents (40 and 38) and two children, full Marketplace price because the household is above the 400% line, in each state's most populous county; CMS plan-year 2027 file, snapshot October 30, 2026. Private range from the carrier rate tables our advisors quote from, both parents and both children included, after the advisors' usual adjustment; health questions apply.

The pattern is the same everywhere: once the credit is gone, the cheapest Marketplace Bronze plan for a family of four runs roughly $1,300 to $1,800 a month for 2027, from about $1,317 in Wayne County, Michigan to about $1,761 in Miami-Dade County, Florida, and the private range starts at a fraction of that. The gap is not because private plans are magic. It is because they are underwritten and the Marketplace plan is not.

Notice too that the cheapest Silver plan in these counties runs $1,779 to $2,339 a month at full price, and the benchmark Silver that the credit is measured against sits just above it. A household one dollar over the line is not losing a small top-up; in Miami-Dade it is losing a credit of about $1,231 a month, roughly $14,800 a year.

What you are actually buying on the private side

A private plan asks health questions. If the household is healthy, the carrier prices it as healthy, which is where the low end of those ranges comes from. The plans our advisors place are generally PPO-style, so the network is broader than the HMO that tends to be the cheapest Marketplace option, deductibles are typically lower, and you can apply in any month of the year rather than waiting for Open Enrollment.

The trade-offs are genuine and you should hear them before you get excited about the number:

  • Underwriting can say no. A carrier can decline an application, charge more, or exclude a specific condition. A parent with a chronic condition or a child in ongoing treatment usually belongs on the Marketplace, where nothing can be excluded, even at full price.
  • It is not ACA coverage. Private plans do not have to cover the ten essential health benefits the same way, and benefits vary by plan. An advisor should walk you through what is and is not covered before you switch, in plain words.
  • Children are priced separately. The ranges above include both parents and both children, at about $80 a month per child, but every carrier handles kids a little differently.

Used correctly, private coverage is the answer for exactly the household this guide describes: healthy, over the line, and looking at a four-figure Marketplace premium for a high-deductible plan. Used carelessly, it is how someone with a condition ends up uninsured for it. The honest approach is to price both, which is what the tool on this site does for your household in about thirty seconds.

Legitimate ways to land under the line

The credit is based on modified adjusted gross income, not gross pay, and several ordinary decisions move that number. None of these are loopholes; they are how the rules work. Confirm any of them with your tax professional before you count on it.

  • Pre-tax retirement contributions. Traditional 401(k), 403(b) and deductible IRA contributions reduce MAGI dollar for dollar. A family at $135,000 that contributes $8,000 to a 401(k) is at $127,000 and back inside the credit. In Hillsborough County that is worth about $1,100 a month in 2027, which is more than the contribution itself.
  • HSA contributions. If you are on an HSA-eligible plan, contributions reduce MAGI as well, up to the annual limit.
  • The self-employed health insurance deduction. Self-employed households deduct premiums above the line, which lowers MAGI, which raises the credit; the two interact and an accountant should run the circular calculation.
  • Timing income. A bonus that lands in January instead of December, or a Roth conversion deferred a year, can keep a borderline household under the line for the year that matters.

What does not work: understating income on the application. The credit is reconciled on your tax return, and an income that comes in above 400% means paying every dollar of advance credit back.

A simple decision checklist

  • Under $132,000 for four (or the equivalent for your household size) and likely to stay there: the Marketplace with your credit almost always wins. Take it.
  • Near the line: run the retirement-contribution maths first. Getting under the line is usually worth thousands.
  • Comfortably over the line and everyone is healthy: get a private quote before you pay full Marketplace price. The tool shows the range instantly and an advisor confirms it after a short health application.
  • Over the line but someone has an ongoing condition: price the Marketplace at full price and treat that as the floor of what good coverage costs. It may still be the right call.

Questions people ask

Is the 400% cliff still in force for 2027?

Yes, for a second year. The enhanced premium tax credits from the American Rescue Plan and the Inflation Reduction Act applied to plan years 2021 through 2025 and expired on December 31, 2025. Congress did not extend them for 2027, so the credit is available only up to 400% of the federal poverty level, with the applicable percentages set by IRS Revenue Procedure 2026-26, unless a new extension passes.

What is the 400% line for my household size?

For 2027 coverage it is $63,840 for one person, $86,560 for two, $109,280 for three and $132,000 for four in the 48 contiguous states and DC, rising by $22,720 for each additional person. These come from the 2026 HHS poverty guidelines, which apply to the 2027 plan year. Alaska and Hawaii use higher guidelines.

Can a private plan cover a pre-existing condition?

Sometimes, at a higher price, and sometimes not at all: the carrier decides after reviewing the application, and it can exclude the condition. Marketplace plans must cover it. That is why a household with ongoing care usually belongs on the Marketplace even when it costs more.

Sources: CMS QHP Landscape PY2027 Individual Medical file (data.healthcare.gov, snapshot October 30, 2026) for Marketplace premiums; HHS 2026 poverty guidelines (91 FR 1797) and IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-26 for the credit rules and limits; carrier rate tables used by our advisors for private ranges. Figures are monthly, non-tobacco, and can change during Open Enrollment.

See your own numbers

Enter your age, household and income and get every Marketplace plan priced for you, your estimated tax credit, and a private plan range, side by side, in about 30 seconds. No medical questions.

Show my price ranges

Related guides

Updated November 8, 2026. How we price explains the data and the maths.

Your own price in 30 secondsShow my price ranges